Equisearch
Welcome to EquiSearch Community Sign in | Join | Help
 
Community Search:
within
Search

This is what not to do when jumping

Last post 08-18-2008 3:03 PM by claire13. 19 replies.
Page 1 of 2 (20 items) 1 2 Next >
Sort Posts: Previous Topic Next Topic
  • 07-06-2008 11:14 AM

    This is what not to do when jumping

    <

    the future belongs to those who belive in the beauty of their dreams
  • 07-06-2008 1:13 PM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    What?

    I saw some pretty good moments in that set of pictures.  Yes there are also some bad days, what happeneds, and might want to go back to basics, but I don't see anything outrageous either.

    It was obviously a schooling show and the pictures look like they are from a children's/adult beginner class.  Everyone starts somewhere and unless you were the picture of perfect equitation the first time you went over a jump (and every time since), well, let he who is without sin cast the first stone.

    I find it in poor taste to post images of other riders (not yourself) on a public message board for ridicule.  I find it even more in poor taste when they are obviously children and beginners.

    I've had some pretty crappy (to put it mildly) trips around the show pen (jumping and flat) that no where near reflect the normal relationship between me and my horse or my normal equitation.  I learned from those moments, but I'd be humiliated and furious if I found that someone else had taken the liberties to point out how horrible I looked on a public forum.  It was embarassing enough to live through the moment, and not all of the situations were preventible through preparation (some of course were, generally my bad days ;) ).

    Crap happens.  Unless they are professionals and thus choose to put themselves in the public eye (and even then I'm not sure how right that is), let them decide if and when they want public critiques...  We have no idea the circumstances behind any of those pictures and even just looking through them I find a few that were obviously just bad jumps as the ones before and after show respectable equitation.
  • 07-06-2008 2:47 PM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

     I see a lot riders jumping fences that are too big for them, but I don't know the back story.  It is not appropriate to post pictures of others for public ridicule on this forum.  



    Solaris -- 16 hh Appendix Quarter Horse = MY DREAM COME TRUE!
  • 07-06-2008 6:09 PM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    I dont quite see the point of this post other than to post - without permission, I am assuming - photographs of a competition showing people jumping their horses!

    Photographs are purely a moment in time and hardly a platform to start up a thread on horse abuse Sad  I didnt think there were too many horses that should be felt sorry for!!!!

    It is in pretty poor taste to post pictures of people on a public forum just to criticise them especially without PERMISSION! 

     



    "IF I DONT LOOK IT WILL FLY AWAY - SOON!"


    Moorah Park Arabians - breeders of
    Moorah Park Miss Tiffany - deceased
    Moorah Park Mickerby - FEI WORLD RANKED ENDURANCE HORSE

    Home of:-
    Springtime Park Carrington - Anglo Gelding
    Charlotte - 1x Q Horse
    Chancey Late Lucy - Palouse Pony
  • 07-07-2008 6:13 AM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    All of us are ocassionally thrown off balance, jump ahead, pop a fence etc.. when jumping. Yet looking at these pictures, there seems to be a trend as the same riders are out of balance at more than one fence. It is really dangerous that their trainer (if they have one) would allow them to keep jumping as they are not solid enough in their riding to do so safely and effectively. I truly hope that they can get quality instruction that will improve their riding, making it a safer activity for both themselves and the horses.

  • 07-07-2008 8:22 AM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    I'm sure I wouldn't like one of those pics. to be me. But I think it is in no poorer taste than say, critising someone for their spelling or grammer in a post.  

    That being said.... There does seem to be a trend among this particular set of riders. They are in poor form, off balance and obviously jumping fences way too high for their ability. This isn't just a few pics taken at the wrong time. I wonder if it wasn't a barn show. It looks to me like these riders all have the same trainer telling them to do what not to do. I, too, feel for these horses. They are obviously well trained and doing their best to get themselves and their riders over the fences.

  • 07-07-2008 11:26 AM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    Hijack warning, sorry.

    thatwindow:
    I'm sure I wouldn't like one of those pics. to be me. But I think it is in no poorer taste than say, critising someone for their spelling or grammer in a post.  


    Or in no poorer taste than in bringing up posts that are months old and irrelevant because you seem to have a problem with a poster?

    I ignored it once, but since you seem to want to bring it up repeatedly I'll address it this time.

    1) That poster chose to post on a public message board.  Thus they chose to have their writing in public on the internet.  These people did not.  It is different.

    2) If someone chooses to crusade for a controversial topic (more power to them) it is in their best interest to put up a professional, well put together, front.  That includes legible text.  I did not go on a grammar crusade over a misspelt word or a single missing punctuation; the post had no punctuation and had so many errors it was nearly illegible.  You may not see it that way, but it was constructive criticism aimed at helping that individual be more effective at what they were trying to do in a post where they wanted comments (I grant they probably didn't want comments on posting style).  I gave someone criticism (that I hoped to be constructive to that individual) to their face (in this case to their monitor) which is different than posting images without the individuals' permission or even knowledge for ridicule (no constructive criticism around when the person isn't there to learn from it and "this is what not to do when jumping" is hardly constructive anyway).

    How a message is presented is important.  Would you vote someone into office that appeared to not be able to write a legible sentence?  I hope not, and the post was about gaining support for a controversial topic; it's in their best interest to appear educated and competent (I'm sure they likely were, so I'm not saying they weren't).  It doesn't take any extra time to add in punctuation and it takes only minimal extra time to do a quick run-through for major errors.

    This is especially true when you want to start up a controversial topic on a message board and are new to the board (as I remember this person being).  Reason being is if you aren't careful about how you write such posts (grammar and wording) you are significantly more likely to come off as an internet troll.  

    Perhaps my post to them was a bit snippier than it would have been otherwise because my perception is that this is what that person was, and I'm sure I could have phrased the post better (I'm only human and this is the internet.  I have bad days.  Also things get written that are meant to be taken one way and because of the medium accidently come out another, etc.), but I still stand behind the content and intent behind the post: if you want to be taken seriously, have people subscribe to your cause, and gain support you need to put up a professional front.  Part of that is making an attempt at complete sentences and proper spelling (notice I said attempt, not perfection).

    Now, I'll be happy to talk to the original poster of that message (and I don't even remember who it was) if they would like me to.  I will even gladly apologize to them for the misunderstanding if my message was misconstrued as something other than constructive criticism by them.  However, since the post was not directed to you I would appreciate it if you drop the issue you seem to have with me over it or take it to PM rather than let it infiltrate other threads months down the road.  Thank you.
  • 07-07-2008 1:18 PM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    (Again, off topic)

    My curiousity got the better of me, so I thought I'd let you know it was "friver."  Total posts, 3, last visited, 6/19/08.

     

    K.C.
    /)__~
    </ </

    VISIT MY PICS!


  • 07-08-2008 1:09 PM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    It's funny that this has come up. I justed posted a new thread called "Lets all try" I was trying to be discreet about the issue of poor puncuation and grammer in posts. I hope it helps, so that we may all stay on subject. 

  • 07-09-2008 9:26 PM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    I think it is unthoughtful and a bit unclassy to post pictures of other riders who are having a bad jumping day. As a rider, and a jumper, I know how it feels to see a picture of myself caught in a bad moment over a jump.  I know that in every lesson, I get one bad spot, and my jump gets a little off balance. It happens to all of us, sometimes for reasons we cannot control. So when you to post pictures of others without permission, I don't understand the reason behind it. If I saw myself, I would be devastated and ashamed...the same way I feel when I see a bad picture of myself that the show photographer took.

     So whatever satisfaction came in return for criticizing these riders, I would hope next time that you would think twice. Maybe one of those riders "next time" is one of us.

     

    That said, yes, some of these riders could use some work on their position to not interfere with their horse.

    Lily
    Thoroughbred x Hanoverian
  • 07-17-2008 7:20 PM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    whats the issue? I only saw the first pic, but I saw a well balanced rider showing a beautiful crest release.  she could stand to heel down a little more, but otherwise quite nice

    maybe there were bad pics later on?



    PM me for Graphics. Look for the OAP, this marks it as one I made. If there is a Copyright symbol I have rights to the photo

    *I tell it how I see it, but do try to not be overly harsh.*
  • 07-22-2008 6:29 AM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    I get what everyone is saying about not ridiculing people who haven't given permission and are apparently beginners, etc.

    However, I just purchased my first horse this year (a 10 yo Appendix Quarter Horse gelding, 15.3 h, chestnut) and we are schooling over fences, and I actually found these pictures extremely interesting from a training perspective.  It does appear to me that these riders are doing courses that are too advanced for them, which is a shame because so many of them are so obviously off-balance.  I know from years of erratic lessons on school horses that this kind of riding does not feel good.  It also appears, as somebody said, that the riders all have the same trainer, since they are (mostly) all making similar mistakes. 

    So for what it's worth, I enjoyed seeing the pictures--not to pick on anybody, because God knows what my horse and I look like over fences ourselves, but because it gave me reminders on what I can work on and remember to avoid doing (heels down!  crest release!  breathe!.)  It also reminded me that there is no shame in doing gymnastics over and over and over until me and my horse have it down pat!

    And considering that this was a photographer's web site for people to buy these pictures, I think that the only people who know there is anything wrong here are other riders.  I think the families of the people in the pictures will still get considerable pleasure from them.   And maybe the riders themselves will learn something from seeing them.  I know that I would, and I'd try to improve my form the next time.

  • 07-23-2008 7:55 AM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    ok I looked at some more pics, though it isn't working to well for me.

     I now see what you mean!  haha.  yes people jumping ahead, elbows sticking out, legs banging back,  a 170 degree open hip angle!  the first rider is quite lovely though, which is the only pic I commented on in my first post.



    PM me for Graphics. Look for the OAP, this marks it as one I made. If there is a Copyright symbol I have rights to the photo

    *I tell it how I see it, but do try to not be overly harsh.*
  • 07-23-2008 9:09 AM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    wow! I did not know I was among the elite riders of the world, who were born being to execute perfect releases, walk on their heels and stay absolutely picture perfect over a fence, even when the horse obviously gets in a sticky spot(as evidenced by the next 2 photos)..I am in awe!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Id love to see photos of all those who chose to critque these poor people. I saw determined, smiling faces on the riders and that is AWESOME for the horse world.We need these people and can do without the snarky comments.

    I am really dissapointed in some people on thie thread... this behavior ranks right up there with that weirdo who does fugly. I will keep striving towards the perfection that so many of you seem to have acheived. :(

    img<http://community.equisearch.com/photos/coyotecreek/images/243455/original.aspx>img
  • 07-24-2008 9:12 AM In reply to

    Re: This is what not to do when jumping

    I quite agree coyote creek, my above post was a clarification of what I had said earlier as I did not fully investigate.

     



    PM me for Graphics. Look for the OAP, this marks it as one I made. If there is a Copyright symbol I have rights to the photo

    *I tell it how I see it, but do try to not be overly harsh.*

Page 1 of 2 (20 items) 1 2 Next >
SPONSORED LINKS